Why should you trust someone who says things you know from
your own experience are false?
Mitchell
Zimmerman
Remember the old saying? Fool me once, shame on you. Fool
me twice, shame on me.
President Trump has fooled too many people too many times –
many more than twice. Perhaps many people are ready to believe anything Trump
says because he attacks people who they enjoy seeing targeted. But what if this
time it is people like us who are actually the targets of Trump’s attacks?
What else can you make of it when Donald Trump tells
flagrant falsehoods about something important to our families’ well-being: the
fact that rising prices are eating up our income? What should you make of it
when Donald Trump denies something you know to be true from your own
experience?
In 2024 Trump promised voters that when he was elected, “inflation
will vanish completely.” He even vowed, further, that “prices
will come down,
and they’ll come down fast, with everything.”
“When I win, I will immediately
bring prices down.”
It has been nearly a year. Prices have not gone down.
Everyone knows this. But Donald Trump refuses to admit it.
Trump: “We have no inflation. We have no inflation.”
On October 31st, Trump was interviewed for the CBS
News’ program Sixty Minutes. When reporter Norah O’Donnell pointed out that
“grocery prices are up,” Trump blew up.
“No, you’re wrong,” he insisted. “Right now they’re going
down. . . . Inflation, I’ve already taken care of. … We have no inflation. We
have no inflation.”
Trump asserted prices have already dropped. “Every price
is down,” he said in
early November. “Everything is way down.” Gasoline prices have “plummeted” and
“we’re at almost $2 for gasoline.”
Really? At a gas pump near you? Here in the real world, on
Thanksgiving weekend, the national average gas price was three dollars a gallon.
“Everything” is certainly not “way down.” Prices are
obviously going up again.
You are not alone if you see a disconnect between Trump’s
pontificating and our reality.
On November 19th Fox
News released a poll on the cost of living. Eight-five
percent of Americans say they are paying more for groceries
than last year. Four out of five say their cost of utilities has gone
up. Two-thirds say their health care expenses and their housing expenses have
increased. “Everything is” not “way down.”
Nope. The
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported the jump in food and other
prices for the first nine months of Trump’s presidency. (Beef up 13%. Oranges
up 15%. Electricity 7%. Natural gas 6%. Gasoline 6%.)
The U.S. Department of Agriculture certainly did not tell
Trump that produce prices are “way down.” The USDA
said food prices would “rise faster than the historical average rate
of growth” in 2025 – and projected food prices would continue to rise nearly as
fast in 2026.
The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Consumer Price Index for September
2025 (the latest month for which data is now available) shows prices 3% higher
than one year ago.
No one misinformed President Trump. He invented his own
lies.
Just making things up that sound good is second nature to
Donald Trump.
Remember he was going
to make Mexico pay for the wall? Cap credit
card interest rates at 10%? Make in-vitro
fertilization treatment free? End
the Ukraine war on Day One? (Trump now claims that was “said in
jest.” Ending a war is a joke?) Provide a tax credit for family caregivers?
(Forgotten on Day One, and certainly when Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill Act
gave the richest
one percent of Americans a $75,000
tax break!)
But it takes a special kind of chutzpah to tell people who
see their grocery prices going up that their grocery prices are going down.
Trump, like one of the Marx Brothers in a 1933 movie, is saying, “Who you gonna
believe, me or your own eyes?”
If you believe your own eyes about the prices you see in the
supermarket and on your utility bill, Trump thinks you’re a sucker – for being
taken in by “a
con job by the Democrats.”
It’s time to ask ourselves: Who’s running the con job? And
what else has Donald Trump been saying that just ain’t so?
Here’s one easy example: Who is paying the tariffs on the
things you buy that come from overseas?
Donald Trump told voters over and over during the 2024
campaign that they
would not be paying for tariffs. Tariffs are “a tax on another
country,” Trump insisted. “It’s not going to be a cost to you, it’s going to be
a cost to another country.”
That was a lie. Ask any business person. Tariffs are a sales
tax that U.S.
importers are paying, and since they are passing the expense on in higher
prices, you are bearing the expense. They are part of the reason prices are
going up.
Trump recently admitted the lie. In response to the soaring
prices of tariff-burdened foods like coffee, tea, and bananas (coffee
is up 20%), Trump recently cut those tariffs, saying
that would bring down coffee prices “in a very short period of time.”
The only way a tariff cut can bring down prices is when tariffs were the reason
prices went up in the first place.
Sometimes Trump’s lies are so obvious it’s hard to believe
even MAGA supporters take them seriously. Consider the lie about renaming the
Gulf of Mexico.
“I called the Gulf of Mexico, the Gulf of America,” Trump
explained, “because to me, it was always the Gulf of America. We have 92
percent of the frontage. Why isn’t it the Gulf of America?”
Let’s look at the map:
The black line shows U.S. coastal frontage from Texas to
Florida. The red line shows the rest of the Gulf’s coastal frontage, along
Mexico and part of Cuba. Does it look to you like the black line is 92% of all
the shoreline? No one could claim that with a straight face. Except Donald
Trump. He thinks Americans are too dumb to notice his lies.
Here is a more consequential lie for the 83
million people – about one in five Americans – who rely on Medicaid for
comprehensive coverage of health and long-term care. What Trump called the “One
Big Beautiful Bill” made savage cuts in the Medicaid program, based on One Big
Ugly Lie.
$1 trillion dollars taken from Medicaid. $1 trillion
given to the one percent.
Trump said
he was going to leave Medicaid alone. “We’re not doing any cutting of
anything meaningful,” he said. “We’re not changing Medicaid.” Immediately after
his Big Beautiful Bill was passed, Trump
repeated the claim that “we’re not going to touch” Medicaid.
False. Trump’s bill will, over a ten year period, hack $1
trillion off Medicaid funding, by making it more difficult for
individuals to qualify or remain qualified for Medicaid, reducing benefit and
reimbursement rates, and other changes. Over
14 million people will lose health coverage.
The American
Medical Association condemned the bill:
“Care will be less accessible, and patients may simply
forego seeing their physician because the lifelines of Medicaid and CHIP [the
Child Health Insurance Program] are severed. … This bill will make patients
sicker. … Acute, treatable illnesses will turn into life-threatening or costly
chronic conditions.”
About one trillion dollars taken from Medicaid is just
about the right amount to pay for the One Big Beautiful Bill’s $1
trillion tax gift to the top one percent of Americans. These
are people who make more than $1,149,000
each year. They will get a much-needed $75,400 tax break next year.
Finally, let’s look at Trump’s lies about undocumented
immigrants. He wants to deport over 10 million people, an action that Trump’s
own Labor Department has said is already making food
shortages and increased food prices likely, and is impacting home
construction, meat packing and the availability of home health aides.
Trump seeks to justify the disruption and downright cruelty
by saying he’s only deporting “the worst of the worst.” But there aren’t
millions of criminals among the immigrants who came to America without proper
authorization. They came seeking a better life or desperate to escape brutal
gang violence in their homelands, and the overwhelming majority are law-abiding
and hard working.
The ice cream man isn’t the “worst of the worst”
Even Fox
news reports that the “worst of the worst” claim is false: “The
majority of people currently detained by ICE have no criminal convictions. Of
those who do, relatively few have been convicted of high-level crimes.”
A U.S. government-funded
study confirmed the point, finding that “undocumented immigrants are
arrested at less than half the rate of native-born U.S. citizens for violent
and drug crimes and a quarter the rate of native-born citizens for property
crimes.”
Common sense tells us Trum
p is lying. ICE is not seizing
people for deportation by the millions by targeting particular individuals
found guilty of serious crimes. By the U.S.
government’s own explanation in court, ICE “contact teams” try to find
undocumented immigrants by looking for individuals who have a Spanish accent or
look Hispanic and who are found in locations such as bus stops, car washes, day
laborer pickup sites, and agricultural sites.
ICE’s targets are not the worst of the worst. In Culver City
they seized a beloved ice
cream man. Law-abiding young people, who were brought here as small
children, are being targeted for deportation from the only country they know,
the U.S.A. when they are about
to graduate from high school. Day laborers at Home Depot. Shoppers in a
Walmart parking lot. Patients in a hospital.
Trump’s lies about immigrants are shameful.
It would take an encyclopedia to list and correct all the
lies Donald Trump has told. When you encounter Trump’s pronouncements
on matters such as whether federal troops are needed in our cities – whether
crime is out of control – whether all third-world immigrants are a threat –
whether voter fraud is a real problem – whether civil rights laws discriminate
against white people – whether the 2020 election was stolen from Trump – or
whether anything Donald Trump does not like to hear must be fake news, ask
yourself: Are groceries cheaper?
Mitchell Zimmerman is an attorney, longtime social activist, and author of the anti-racism thriller Mississippi Reckoning. He's also a longtime contributor to Progressive Charlestown. His writing can also be found on his Substack, Reasoning Together with Mitchell Zimmerman.Subscriptions to Reasoning Together with Mitchell Zimmerman are free at this time. If you find my writing of value, please like, subscribe and recommend Reasoning Together to your friends. Thank you.
You may also be interested in my road-trip novel / social thriller Mississippi Reckoning. Read an excerpt. Read the Progressive Charlestown review HERE.