Vaccine
mandates needed now more than ever
By
Will Collette
When Tuesday’s COVID transmission rate was updated at 2 PM, I was shocked to see
it at 236.3 per 100,000 when it was “only” 208 yesterday. The Health Department
also reported six more COVID deaths.
I
don’t recall seeing such a steep one-day jump in either transmission or death for
months.
The
rate of transmission tells us how widely COVID is passing through the
population. For perspective, the transmission rate was only 12 per 1000,000 on
July 4 so our community transmission rate has increased by nearly a factor of 20.
The total number of RI’s COVID
dead crossed
2,800.
Meanwhile,
accidental Governor Dan McKee is trying to decide whether to go through with
his own plan to mandate vaccination for health care workers.
I
think it’s a no-brainer: any health care worker who doesn’t believe in
vaccination should not be a health care worker. Period. I would not want to be
treated by one.
Yet
33 state Representatives including Charlestown’s own Blake “Flip” Filippi,
village idiot Justin Price, conservative Westerly Democrat Sam Azzinaro and
Charlestown’s Probate Judge Bob Craven signed a letter to McKee asking him NOTto mandate vaccination of health care workers.
I
was surprised to see Bob Craven’s name on the list so I e-mailed him.
Dear Bob,
I ask you to
reconsider signing on to Doc Corvese’s and Flip Filippi’s letter asking the
Governor to lift the COVID vaccine mandate on health care workers.
Frankly, at this
stage of the pandemic, it is a disgrace that ALL health workers aren’t already
vaccinated, especially since they were top priority and first in line when the
vaccines came out last winter.
Unvaccinated
health care workers – especially those who work in nursing homes – should have
been fired last March if they failed to get vaccinated in January and February.
They of all
people should know better that we cannot control this pandemic without more
people getting vaxxed. Fortunately, unvaccinated health workers are outliers;
most health care workers understand the value of vaccines and have been vaxxed.
These outliers will not be missed.
This is not
about personal choice but about public health and safety. Vaccine mandates
wiped out smallpox and polio.
You probably
know that Ray Hull has already withdrawn his name from this letter. I hope you
will do likewise and urge other House leadership who signed on to take their
names off.
I
received a one-line reply:
“We
can’t make people get a vaccine and I don’t want there to be a lack of health
care workers”
I challenged Bob on both points, sending him a link to the US
Supreme Court’s Jacobson v. Massachusetts (1905) which is the controlling
decision affirming vaccine mandates as well as examples of the many other
court-approved measures where the public health rights of the public override
individual choice.
Further, health care workers had been eligible for the vaccines
since January and should have gotten their shots long ago. I have not hear back
from Bob on my second message.
Hospitalizations and deaths in Rhode Island, as elsewhere, are
still largely limited to the unvaccinated, including many children under 12 who
are not yet eligible to be vaccinated.
A recent study by the
American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) shows Rhode Island to have the third-highest
per capita rate (behind Tennessee and South Carolina) of all states for
COVID infections in children.
One prominent death last week was Barrington Police Sergeant
Gino Caputo after an agonizing five weeks. WPRI
reports his widow Cindy Caputo “said her husband chose not to get vaccinated against COVID-19
because he was healthy, had no underlying medical conditions and rarely got
sick.”
Sgt. Caputo’s sister Rosamaria
Gallucci said:
“A lot of people are going back and forth on
vaccination, but the truth is, they really need to get vaccinated. They need to
get vaccinated because this is a perfect example of what will happen if they
don’t.”
Just
over half of all Americans have been fully vaccinated. Roughly 64% of all Rhode
Islanders (including the young, ineligible children) have been fully
vaccinated. The outliers – the Trumpnuts and anti-vaxxers – represent a public
health threat to all of us.
Our
133,000 young Rhode Island children under 12 are especially vulnerable. They
are being hospitalized and dying. Many will suffer long-term effects.
Those
of us who have been fully vaccinated face the threat of vaccine-resistant
mutations of the coronavirus. One such mutation is already out there, the “mu
variant,” which has been detected in Rhode Island.
According
to Health
Department data, as of September 14, 145,000 eligible Rhode Islanders have
not been vaccinated.
This
minority has chosen to threaten the lives of small children, the state’s
economy and our well-being. The fact that some of them are health care workers
is a disgrace.
We
cannot simply allow ourselves to continue to drift through this pandemic
without a sharpened focus on what it takes to end it.
That
means mandatory masking, vaccination and social distancing. It means major
upgrades in ventilation and air quality in schools, businesses and public
places. It means restricting travel from states where it is official policy to
allow COVID to run wild, such as Texas and Florida.
Hospitals
and other health care facilities should have triage measures in place to put
the willfully unvaccinated at the bottom of the priority list for ER and ICU
treatment.
Let’s
stop coddling the unvaccinated. They are, by choice, putting themselves and all of us in harm’s
way.