Menu Bar

Home           Calendar           Topics          Just Charlestown          About Us

Friday, December 11, 2020

What do Donald Trump, Rudy Giuliani, Chris Christie and Ben Carson have in common?

Giuliani leaves hospital after getting drug 'cocktail' so rare states distribute it by lottery

Mark Sumner, Daily Kos Staff

By Nick Anderson
Ten months into the pandemic, the monoclonal antibody “cocktails” developed by Eli Lilly and Regeneron are one of the few treatments proven to be highly effective against COVID-19. 

Unfortunately they are both expensive and difficult to manufacture, which made Donald Trump’s promise to make these drugs available to everyone for free even more ridiculous than his usual lies. 

The total number of available doses is not enough to treat the Americans who test positive for coronavirus on a single day.

In the real world, these drugs are so scarce that states and hospitals distribute them by lottery. Medical organizations are hastily convening ethics boards to determine how to hand out drugs that are both highly effective and extremely limited. 

It might seem that they could be reserved for only those in most dire circumstances, but that’s not the way they work. The drugs are most effective when administered early, before the onset of serious symptoms. 

The tiny fraction of patients who receive these drugs have much improved odds of never developing serious issues like those now plaguing millions of Americans. They just have to get very, very lucky … like Donald Trump, Chris Christie, Ben Carson, and Rudy Giuliani.  

After Trump announced Giuliani’s illness on Monday, he was apparently given immediate hospital care. This despite the fact that hospitals all across the country are overrun with COVID-19 patients and many have been restricting access to just those in severe distress. Giuliani was not in severe distress. He got, as he explained to The New York Times, “celebrity treatment.”

Giuliani explained more fully to a New York radio station, using terms that sound distressingly similar to Trump’s Access Hollywood hot mic statement … “If it wasn’t me, I wouldn’t have been put in a hospital frankly,” said Giuliani. “Sometimes when you’re a celebrity, they’re worried if something happens to you they’re going to examine it more carefully, and do everything right.”

Trump apparently arranged for his personal attorney to get the same treatment that he got—right down to the inappropriate application of the steroid dexamethasone to someone who was not receiving breathing assistance. 

Trump also intervened direction in Carson’s treatment, insisting on the same regime even though physicians didn’t feel it was appropriate. And now, just three days later, Giuliani is heading home, feeling fine.

Considering his current position, it’s reasonable that Trump was given special access to an experimental drug that, at the time, had not even been given emergency authorization by the FDA. 

But why Chris Christie? Why Ben Carson? Why Rudy Giuliani? Under what possible justification is there such a thing as “celebrity healthcare,” where it comes at the cost of providing treatment that is denied to most Americans?

Trump’s pals aren’t alone. The Times notes a wealthy businessman was also able to call in a few favors and get the antibody treatment when he fell ill from COVID-19. This at a time when the entire state of California has been given just 23,000 doses of monoclonal antibodies to address 794,000 active cases of COVID-19. 

That shortage comes down to this: Somewhere, someone very well could have died so that Rudy Giuliani could have his dose of an exceedingly rare treatment. Hopefully, Giuliani’s doctors didn’t follow Trump’s treatment exactly … because Trump actually got four times the amount of antibodies given to other patients.

In addition to being grossly unfair and cruel, the distribution of the drugs to the political class is creating a massive disconnect in the view of COVID-19. Giuliani, despite being on his way home from his own treatment, took time out to criticize masks and social distancing because, he said, COVID-19 is “a treatable disease.” 

The image of Trump, Christie, Giuliani and others popping back up in days without serious symptoms or lingering effects is just as powerful as watching these men go through their day without masks and ignoring rules. It creates an impression that there’s nothing to worry about. 

On the day Rudy Giuliani was sent home feeling ”100 percent better,” 3,243 Americans died from COVID-19. That’s more than D-Day or Pearl Harbor or 9/11. It’s getting more and more difficult to find days in history that offer comparable degrees of carnage. Let's just hope that there's no point in the future where someone says "this is worse than COVID-19.”