Deer get blamed, but that may be an unjust accusation
Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies
EDITOR'S NOTE: The Providence Journal reports that the town of New Shoreham, better known as Block Island, is considering whether to wipe out its entire deer population (estimated at between 150-900) to curb tick-borne diseases. Before committing to deer genocide, Block Island leaders should check out new research published by the National Academy of Science that shows the tick life cycle is much more complicated. - Will Collette
Tick-borne illnesses are becoming increasingly common across
the United States, and Lyme disease remains the most frequently reported.
Nearly 500,000 Americans are diagnosed each year. The infection is caused by
the bacterium Borrelia burgdorferi, which typically reaches humans
through the bite of an infected blacklegged tick. Antibiotics can treat Lyme
disease, but without treatment, the infection may affect the joints, heart, and
nervous system. Some patients also experience symptoms that persist over time.
Now, one of the longest-running studies of Lyme disease
ecology is challenging several assumptions about what makes the disease more
likely to spread. For more than 35 years, scientists at the Cary Institute of
Ecosystem Studies in Millbrook, New York, have tracked the complicated
relationships among ticks, mice, oak trees, predators, and weather. Their
research has uncovered unexpected patterns that could help predict when people
face greater exposure to infected ticks.
A new study published in Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences brings together nine of the project's most surprising
discoveries. The findings show how decades of observations can reveal
connections that shorter studies might miss.
"On balance, these surprises have enriched our knowledge of this system, helping us to inform management of tick-borne disease risk," said lead author Richard Ostfeld, a disease ecologist at the Cary Institute who leads the research program alongside Shannon LaDeau.
According to Ostfeld, the extensive data collected over the
years have been essential for separating meaningful ecological patterns from
coincidences and statistical fluctuations.
"Studies of this depth and length are incredibly
rare," said LaDeau. "This research has followed an ecological
community -- including oak trees, mammals, and microorganisms -- examining how
interactions like predation, parasitism, and competition shape the system over
time. The evolution of understanding summarized in this paper is something you
simply cannot get without such a long-term and system-focused study."
Deer May Play a Smaller Role in Lyme Disease Risk Than
Expected
When Lyme disease first gained recognition in the United
States during the 1980s, white-tailed deer were considered a likely driver of
rising tick populations. Hunters frequently encountered deer carrying numerous
adult ticks, suggesting that areas with more deer might also produce more
ticks.
The reasoning seemed straightforward. Although deer cannot
pass the Lyme disease bacterium to ticks, they provide blood meals for adult
female ticks. Scientists suspected that larger deer populations would allow
more female ticks to reproduce, eventually increasing the number of young ticks
capable of spreading the infection.
But decades of monitoring have produced a different picture.
On the Cary Institute's 2,000-acre forested research property in Dutchess
County, New York, researchers found no statistically significant connection
between deer numbers and the abundance of nymphal ticks. Nymphs are immature
ticks responsible for much of the Lyme disease transmission to humans.
"We had detected a weak positive relationship between
deer and subsequent nymph abundance over short subsets of the data," said
Ostfeld, "but the whole data set in its entirety shows no such
thing."
Mice Are a Much Stronger Predictor of Tick Surges
While deer populations failed to predict the abundance of
nymphal ticks, mouse populations showed a much clearer relationship.
Years with especially large mouse populations were followed
by approximately 40% more nymphal ticks the next year. White-footed mice are
particularly important because they provide excellent blood meals for tick
larvae and are highly effective at transmitting Borrelia burgdorferi to
those feeding on them.
Once infected as larvae, ticks can retain the bacteria as
they develop into nymphs. When these nymphs take another blood meal, they can
pass the infection to humans.
The findings suggest that tracking mouse populations could
provide a valuable early warning of unusually high tick numbers.
How Acorns Can Predict Tick Populations Two Years Ahead
One of the most unexpected discoveries involves something
that might seem entirely unrelated to Lyme disease: acorns.
Oak trees periodically produce exceptionally large crops of
acorns in synchronized events known as acorn masting. These unusually
productive years provide an abundance of food for forest rodents, allowing
mouse populations to expand during the following year.
That increase in mice then supports larger numbers of young
ticks. As a result, the researchers found that a particularly heavy acorn crop
can reliably predict an increase in nymphal ticks two years later.
The relationship reveals a remarkable sequence of events in
which the reproductive cycle of forest trees helps determine future tick
abundance. It also offers researchers another potential tool for anticipating
periods of greater Lyme disease exposure.
Why More Mice Don't Always Mean More Infected Ticks
Although mouse abundance helps predict how many nymphal
ticks will appear, the researchers discovered that it does not consistently
predict what percentage of those ticks will carry Lyme disease bacteria.
Initially, scientists expected both measures to rise
together. Because mice are efficient transmitters of B. burgdorferi, an
increase in mice seemed likely to produce not only more ticks but also a
greater proportion of infected ticks.
Early observations appeared to support that idea. However,
as additional years of data accumulated, the apparent relationship gradually
disappeared.
"It kept me up at night," said Ostfeld,
"because it meant that my understanding of how the system works was
incomplete or wrong."
The explanation appears to involve the other animals that
share the forest with mice. Skunks, squirrels, and opossums also serve as hosts
for feeding ticks, but most are much less effective at passing the Lyme disease
bacterium to them.
When these animals are abundant, more larval ticks may feed
on hosts that are unlikely to infect them. This can reduce the percentage of
nymphal ticks carrying the bacteria, even when mouse populations are high.
"So the infection prevalence in the nymphs really
depends on how all the larval tick meals are distributed across all the
hosts," explained Ostfeld. "It would have been convenient if one host
predicted that for us, but that has not been the case."
This finding highlights an important distinction between the
total number of ticks in an environment and the proportion carrying the
pathogen. Predicting the risk of infection requires understanding the broader
community of animals that ticks feed on, not simply counting mice.
Extreme Heat and Cold May Not Kill Ticks in the Wild
Weather has also produced some unexpected results.
Earlier laboratory experiments suggested that exposure to
intense heat or severe cold could kill blacklegged ticks. Yet observations in
natural habitats revealed that ticks are surprisingly capable of surviving
these conditions.
Researchers believe ticks protect themselves from
temperature extremes by retreating into deeper soil layers or hiding beneath
fallen leaves, where conditions are less severe than at the surface.
However, the long-term data also revealed a more complicated
relationship with temperature. Years that are warmer overall tend to be
followed by fewer nymphal ticks than usual, despite the ability of individual
ticks to withstand short periods of extreme heat.
At the same time, warmer conditions generally favor mouse
populations, which can lead to more ticks. These opposing effects make it
difficult to predict how changing temperatures will ultimately influence Lyme
disease risk.
What 35 Years of Research Mean for Lyme Disease
Prevention
Taken together, the discoveries show that Lyme disease risk
depends on a network of ecological interactions that is complicated but not
entirely unpredictable.
Mouse abundance, for example, provides a stronger indicator
of future nymphal tick numbers than deer abundance at the study site.
Similarly, unusually harsh winters may not reduce tick populations as
dramatically as previously expected.
By understanding these patterns, public health officials may
be better equipped to anticipate periods of increased tick exposure and develop
more effective prevention strategies.
Still, important questions remain, particularly about how
climate change will affect ticks, the animals they feed on, and the oak trees
that influence rodent populations.
"You would expect that a warming climate, which makes
life better for the mice, would eventually make life better for the ticks, but
we have not seen that so far," said Ostfeld. "We need to know what to
expect from the different manifestations of climate change, which are sometimes
warmer and drier, and sometimes warmer and wetter. The time of year when it's
very warm also matters to ticks, oaks, and acorn production."
The research site in Dutchess County has undergone
significant environmental changes since monitoring began in 1991. Climate
shifts, changes to the surrounding landscape, and the arrival of invasive
species have all altered the conditions in which the forest's plants and
animals live.
Researchers intend to continue following these changes to determine how ticks and their hosts respond over time. Their work could provide increasingly valuable insights into how future environmental changes will influence human exposure to Lyme disease and other infections carried by ticks.
Journal Reference:
- Richard S. Ostfeld, Shannon L. LaDeau, Kelly Oggenfuss, Charles D. Canham, Michael Fargione, Raymond J. Winchcombe, Felicia Keesing. The ecology of Lyme disease: Long-term data, surprises, and a synthesis. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2026; 123 (34) DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2610907123
