Menu Bar

Home           Calendar           Topics          Just Charlestown          About Us

Wednesday, September 11, 2019

Risks and benefits of mosquito spraying

By TIM FAULKNER/ecoRI News staff
ImageEastern equine encephalitis (EEE) is an insidious virus. It kills about 40 percent of humans who become infected, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

A third of those afflicted suffer permanent neurological damage. The rest recover with little or no long-term health effects.

This year one human case of EEE has been reported in Rhode Island, on Aug. 30. The West Warwick resident died Sept. 8, the state’s first fatal human EEE case since 2007, according to the Rhode Island Department of Health.

Seven people have been infected in Massachusetts. A resident of Fairhaven, Mass., died from the virus in mid-August.

The virus is transmitted by mosquitoes and is prevalent along the East Coast, but the virus is most common in the freshwater swamps of Florida and southeastern Massachusetts, where mosquitoes breed in large numbers.

Although the virus is always present, it spreads in late summer and early fall. The threat subsides after the first frost kills off much of the mosquito population.

The pesticide Anvil 10+10 is the preferred insecticide used to kill mosquitoes. Spray trucks and aerial misting are the most common methods for releasing the chemical. Each treatment creates a fog of droplets that attach to and kill insects.

Anvil poses few short-term health risks to humans, but the poison can last up to two months in soil. It’s highly toxic to freshwater fish, invertebrates, amphibians, and other insects such as honeybees.

Most applications occur at night and early morning, when bees are inside their hives. But not all colonies stay in their hives at night. A recent story by WBUR in Boston noted that some beekeepers put wet sheets over their hives to reduce pesticide exposure.

Anvil has two primary ingredients: sumithrin and piperonyl butoxide. Sumithrin, or d-phenothrin, is a general-purpose pesticide used indoors to kill ants; in shampoos to treat head lice; and on pets to kills fleas and ticks. Piperonyl butoxide is a petroleum solvent similar to paint thinner and kerosene.

It’s unclear if Anvil is an endocrine disruptor. Experimental studies have found that high exposure to piperonyl butoxide causes liver tumors in rats and mice.

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) doesn’t consider Anvil toxic to plants.

Due to the infrequency of treatment and the fact that Anvil breaks down quickly in sunlight and water, human health effects are considered rare, although no studies have been done to determine if Anvil causes any long-term human health impacts.

Short-term exposure can impact the nervous system, causing a loss of coordination, tremors or tingling, and numbness on the skin. Anvil can irritate the eyes, skin, nose, throat, or lungs. Increased exposure can trigger vomiting and depression.

Children are at greater risk than adults to health effects. In communities where applications are occurring, people and pets should stay indoors during treatment. Windows and doors should be closed and air conditioners turned off.

Organic farmers are exempt from the aerial spraying. Homegrown fruits and vegetables should be rinsed in water after an application.

Other than organic farms, open bodies of water, such as reservoirs, some coastal areas, and unpopulated natural areas will be excluded from spraying.

In Massachusetts, 36 communities are classified at critical risk, 42 at high risk, and 115 at moderate risk for the EEE virus. 

In all, 110,000 acres in portions of 21 communities in Rhode Island will be treated. Some of the areas abut portions of Massachusetts where EEE has been detected.

On Sept. 5, Rhode Island dispersed larvicide pellets in “swampy areas” near Central Falls and in Westerly and West Warwick. Granules of Bti, a naturally occurring bacterium, were dispersed by helicopter. According to the EPA, Bti is not a risk to humans.

Bti produces toxins that target the larvae of mosquitoes, black flies, and fungus gnats. These toxins don’t harm other insects such as honeybees. Bti is approved for pest control in organic farming.