Menu Bar

Home           Calendar           Topics          Just Charlestown          About Us

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Board of Elections rejects two of three challenges in Charlestown’s general election

Teachable moment: do your homework

By Will Collette

Hopkinton Chariho critic
Diane Tefft cowboyed up
for the heating
I reported just days ago that close calls on Charlestown Ballot Question 7, the bond referendum to fund construction of the new Chariho Elementary School and the final composition of the Charlestown Town Council drew challenges.

Ballot Question #7, which passed by only 2 votes, reduces the term of office for Planning Commission members from six years to four. Planning Commissar-For-Life and Charlestown Citizens Alliance (CCA) leader Ruth Platner was furious at this result and filled for a recount.

The Chariho Elementary School $116 million construction bond passed by a margin of 158 votes out of the combined total of votes from Charlestown, Hopkinton and Richmond.

As on so many Chariho matters, Charlestown voters overwhelmingly supported the measure by a margin high enough to overcome the no votes from Hopkinton and Richmond. Hopkinton MAGA-nut Dianne Tefft challenged this result and sought a recount.

Finally, CCA -endorsed Town Council candidate Sasha Puchalski challenged her sixth place – and losing – result, beaten by 24 votes by Charlestown Residents United (CRU) incumbent Stephen Stokes.

The Rhode Island Board of Elections (BOE) held a hearing on November 17 to address these challenges as well as several others from other municipalities around the state. You can see the video on YouTube HERE.

I’ll address Sasha Puchalski’s challenge first because it was the least complicated. Even though Puchalski was a no-show at the hearing, the Board accepted her request as valid, based on her standing as a candidate as well as the slim 24-vote margin.

They directed that the ballots be re-feed into the counting machines to determine the accuracy of the count.

After the mechanical recount, the final outcome changed by one vote – against Puchalski – so Steve Stokes was certified the winner by 25 votes.

Ruth Platner (right) showed up for the hearing
with her twin separated at birth, CCA Council member
 Bonnita Van Slyke (Screen shot from BOE video)
Ruth Platner’s challenge to Question #7’s passage and Diane Tefft’s challenge to the results of the Chariho bond question were both denied and for the same reason: lack of standing.

In law, standing or locus standi is a condition that a party seeking a legal remedy must show they have, by demonstrating to the court, sufficient connection to and harm from the law or action challenged to support that party's participation in the case. Click HERE for more detail.

The Board of Elections has a set of regulations that govern who has the right to challenge an election result. 

Both Tefft and Platner admitted to the Board they were unaware of the criteria and had not read the rules. For Platner, this isn’t the first time she has failed to do her homework.

As the general counsel for the Board of Elections pointed out, there were ways that both Tefft and Platner could have met the standing requirements, had they followed the rules. 

Both Tefft and Platner urged the BOE to loosen the rules, especially when it comes to challenges to the results of ballot questions, and the Board seemed sympathetic but still denied their requests.

That closes the book on Election 2026 in Charlestown.