Science taketh with one hand and giveth with the other
By Columbia Climate School
![]() |
| The end of a glaciation. Prominent trimline marks the 1960 extent of the Barnes Ice Cap. The dark-colored landscape hosts mature vegetation and lichen cover, whereas the light-colored rock is vegetation-free. Ice margin retreat from this trimline has reversed ~2,000 years of ice margin expansion. Credit: Nicolás Young |
An ice cap in northern Canada began expanding about 2,000
years ago, according to research published in Science. The researchers
argue that this growth marked the beginning of Earth’s next glacial period. By
the 1960s, however, warmer summers had reversed the process, causing the ice to
retreat.
“It was just getting started, everything was normal, the
next glaciation was about to happen—and yet it stopped,” says Nicolás Young, a
geochemist at the Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, part of the Columbia
Climate School. “It’s a very powerful example of how we have jolted the
system.”
Young, fellow Lamont geochemist Joerg Schaefer, and their
colleagues investigated the surviving remnant of the Laurentide Ice Sheet. That
enormous ice mass covered much of Canada and the northern United States from
about 95,000 to 20,000 years ago. At its largest, it extended from above the
Arctic Circle to Illinois, with ice more than two miles (3.2 kilometers) thick
in places.
The Ice Sheet That Never Fully Disappeared
Today, the Laurentide survives as the Barnes Ice Cap, an ice
mass roughly the size of Delaware on central Baffin Island in Nunavut, Canada.
“People always say that it disappeared, but that’s not true,” says Young.
The Laurentide repeatedly expanded and retreated after
widespread continental glaciation began about 2.6 million years ago. The team
wanted to determine whether its remaining ice had once occupied an even smaller
area than it does today before growing again.
Finding the moment an ice sheet stopped shrinking and began rebuilding is difficult because advancing glaciers usually erase the evidence of their earlier boundaries. Barnes offered an unusual way around that problem: plants preserved beneath the ice.
Buried Plants Reveal The Ice’s Return
Unlike most glaciers, the Barnes Ice Cap is frozen to its
bedrock and does not slide over the ground. When it expanded, it buried
vegetation instead of scraping it away. Its retreat since 1960 has gradually
exposed those preserved plants.
Researchers dated the vegetation using carbon-14, a harmlessly radioactive form of atmospheric carbon that living organisms absorb. After an organism dies, its carbon-14 decays at a predictable rate, allowing scientists to estimate when the plants died as the ice advanced over them.
“If you do this enough times, you can actually develop a
timeline of that ice margin systematically advancing over plants. You’re
actually tracking the expansion of that ice margin,” says Young.
Combining samples from Barnes with vegetation exposed by
recently melted smaller ice caps nearby, the team reconstructed the region’s
climate history. The Laurentide reached its smallest extent about 3,000 years
ago. Roughly 1,000 years later, conditions became cold enough for ice to
accumulate again.
When Does A Glacial Period Begin?
The researchers propose that this first renewed growth
should count as the beginning of a glacial period. That definition places the
starting point long before ice sheets spread across continents.
Earlier modeling studies have suggested that the next
glaciation would remain thousands or even tens of thousands of years away.
Young and his colleagues argue that waiting for enormous continental ice sheets
to form overlooks the much earlier stages of their development.
Their findings also revisit controversial claims made by
some climate scientists in the 1970s that another ice age was approaching. “It
actually was happening,” Young says. “They couldn’t quite prove it, but now we
sort of have the evidence.”
The process would have unfolded far too slowly to transform
the climate within a human lifetime. Young says noticeable cooling would have
taken thousands of years, while restoring Laurentide’s continental reach would
have required about 30,000 years. In the team’s interpretation, warming
interrupted that process near its beginning.
A Vanishing Starting Point for Future Ice Sheets
By the 1960s, the Barnes Ice Cap was losing more ice during
summer than it gained during winter. Models project that it will melt
completely within the next few centuries. “That will be the true very last
remains of the Laurentide, disappearing for good,” Young says.
Its loss could also reshape the conditions for future
glaciations. The Laurentide once provided a ready starting point for expansion
when the climate cooled. Its frigid mass supported feedback processes that
encouraged more ice to accumulate.
With greenhouse gas concentrations elevated, scientists
cannot say when another glaciation might begin. If continental ice sheets
eventually grow again, they may have to develop without this surviving
foundation.
“What has been an extremely natural and predictable
phenomenon is now gone,” says Young.
References:
“Late Holocene reexpansion of the Laurentide Ice Sheet” by
Nicolás E. Young, Gifford H. Miller, Martha Raynolds, Helga Bueltmann, Scott J.
Lehman, Jonathan H. Raberg, Kylie Seward, Simon L. Pendleton, John T. Andrews,
Patrick J. Webber and Joerg M. Schaefer, 22 October 2026, Science.
DOI: 10.1126/science.aed3379
“Has the next ice age already come and gone?” by Shaun A.
Marcott, 22 October 2026, Science.
DOI: 10.1126/science.aem3295
