Enough with the irresponsible fearmongering!
By Will Collette
Since its founding
in 2008, the Charlestown Citizens Alliance (CCA) used fear to gain control
over Charlestown town government and to stay in power for a decade until its
ouster in the 2022 general election.
The CCA’s leader and founder, Ruth Platner, has an
extraordinary record of conjuring up enemies and boogeymen that only she and
the CCA can conquer. As chair of Charlestown's Planning Commission, she has a platform to spread false fear. However, over the years, just about all these existential threats
have been either imaginary or grossly exaggerated.
Ruth’s most persistent boogeyman has been trumped up fear
that Amtrak will cut a swath through northern Charlestown, obliterating
precious farmland as well as natural and historic treasures. Amtrak gave this
boogeyman a name when they included it in a 2016 draft preliminary long-term
plan: “the Old Saybrook-Kenyon Bypass.” I call it the “Charlestown Choo-Choo Hoax” because it was a goofy plan that never had chance of happening.
She's trying to raise this dead issue again, as you can read for yourself HERE. This was posted on Saturday and is her third post on the Charlestown Choo-Choo in the past month.
A stretch of the Northeast Corridor between New Haven and
Westerly runs right along the shoreline in Connecticut. In my last job before
retirement, I commuted to Manhattan several times a month, always taking the
train and loving every minute of its passage through the salt marshes between
the Westerly station and New London. I’d ride on the seaward side, count osprey
nests and wonder at the beauty of that stretch, easily my favorite of any
between Boston and Richmond, VA.
But that section of track faces natural destruction, either
in some major storm or from climate-driven sea level rise, severing the
Northeast Corridor rail line. It will have to be replaced.
The Old Saybrook-Kenyon Bypass was an option offered in an
Amtrak in a 2016 planning document that the CCA-controlled town government
failed to read. As CCA leader and Town Council President Tom Gentz said at the
time, “Who has time to wade through that?”
People in eastern Connecticut were the first to begin protesting the plan. In January
2017, chagrined CCA leaders tried to catch up by painting the Old
Saybrook-Kenyon Bypass as the end of the world as we know it, at least for Charlestown.
I tried to point out the chances of the Bypass were slim to none, given that
newly elected Donald Trump hates trains and would never commit to a
multi-billion infrastructure project in the ultra-Blue northeast. The project
had no Congressional support, and in fact, Congress drastically cut Amtrak
funding for Northeast Corridor improvements.
I speculated at the time that the Bypass would only be built if
Trump privatized Amtrak and sold it either to Elon Musk or one of his sons.
Look, nobody liked the Bypass. I didn’t like the Bypass.
Even Amtrak began distancing themselves from it. They quickly issued a legally
binding Record of Decision in July 2017 effectively killing the plan
only six months after Charlestown first heard of it.
That should have been the end of it. But Ruth Platner felt
the CCA got so much mileage out of supposedly blocking this sketchy threat that
she keeps trying to revive it to help the CCA make a political comeback. This is the fifth time she's tried to fire up
Charlestown over this dead project.
Look back at Platner’s 2021 claim that “They’re Back!” See how she tried to stir the pot again in 2022 and especially weird move in 2024 attempting to use AI to
simulate what a new rail line would look like.
She's at it again, recycling the same claims of a Charlestown
Armageddon. On May 26, she wrote (her emphasis included):
“Amtrak made an announcement on May 21, 2026, that the
study required by the FRA’s 2017 Record of Decision had finally received
federal government and other funding to proceed. Amtrak
estimates that the study—the New Haven to Providence Capacity Planning
Study—will take up to two years.
“… The selection of the new preferred alternative
will be the outcome of the study. We’ll keep you updated as we learn
more, and we may also need your help in contacting our federal and state
officials as we move through the planning process. We are committed to
protecting Charlestown and the natural resources and public and private
property that would be destroyed if anything like the “Old Saybrook to
Kenyon Bypass” returns.”
I suggest you read the actual report HERE: New Haven to
Providence Capacity Planning Study.
I read it. Carefully. Line by line. Guess what I
found?
Nothing, absolutely nothing about the Old Saybrook-Kenyon
bypass that died 10 years ago. It’s as if it never existed. This supposedly alarming document is nothing more than a watered-down version of Amtrak's ongoing effort to try to figure out how to improve service from New Haven to Providence. On June 20, Platner's shocking reveal is that Amtrak has created a website! OMG, the horror!
But in the actual report, the only concrete item I found in the report pertaining to our area was
support for making the popular improvements at the Westerly Amtrak station that
our state Senator Victoria Gu has been campaigning for.
So, Ruth: STOP IT! Sure, CCA’s formula for winning elections
is to claim there are monsters under every bed that only you can kill. But your
cynical attempts to manipulate people’s fears come at a terrible cost.
Here's what I mean:
From 1982 to 1999, I was organizing director for two national environmental groups, first at Lois Gibbs' Center for Health and Environmental Justice, then the Citizens Coal Council. I worked with local citizens' groups to fight hazardous waste dumps, incinerators, coal mines, sludge lagoons and more. These fights were very intense, so intense that I learned early on that they could cause marriages to break up and, in some cases, suicide.
My staff and I were careful to NEVER exaggerate or fear-monger because that only increases the stress. I'm already hearing that Platner's irresponsible efforts to jack up tension over the Charlestown Choo-Choo is indeed doing just that.
And if that's not convincing, just look at what Donald Trump's lies and exaggerated threats are doing to his followers and the rest of the country.
During the 2024 election, I catalogued all the various
threats Platner has used over the years: How the Charlestown Citizens Alliance used fake enemies and
bogus emergencies to gain and keep power.
Looks like I’m going to need to do an updated version.