Recounts requested of votes for Town Council, Planning Commission ballot question and Chariho bond
By Will Collette
In every election, there are inevitably close calls and disappointed losers. It’s hard to judge which hurts most: losing by a handful of votes or being whipped in a landslide.
Now that all ballots have been counted, three election
results of interest to Charlestown are drawing demands for recounts. The
Secretary of State’s final vote count shows the approval of the Chariho
Elementary school construction bond, the election of the five members of the
Charlestown Town Council and the passage of Charlestown ballot Question 7, by close margins.
However, only one of these changed the Election night result
– Charlestown Question 7 that reduces the term of office for Planning
Commission members from the current six years to four.
On Election Night, Question 7 looked like it had been
rejected by a razor-thin 4 vote margin. However, the final numbers showed
Question 7 being APPROVED by 2 votes. CCA leader and Planning Commissar Ruth
Platner is challenging that result and has asked for a recount.
The CCA bitterly opposed Question 7, claiming that Charlestown NEEDS to have Planning Commission members serve for six years so they could see major projects through to the end. I guess they believe it takes six years to talk projects to death, although four years should certainly be enough for them to kill the funding and chase investors away from projects Platner and the CCA dislike.
I supported Question 7 although I believe the real problem
with the Planning Commission lies in Charlestown being the only municipality in
Rhode Island that still elects its planning board. After the state passed
legislation attempting to de-politicize planning by switching to appointed
planning boards, 38 municipalities complied. Charlestown did not, using a
loophole to continue with its CCA-controlled, hyper-politicized elected
Planning Commission.
Of course, nothing can change how politically charged major projects inevitably become, but appointed boards seem less likely to frame every decision based on how it might affect their political future.
All five Charlestown Town Council seats were up for
re-election. Winners were the five top vote-getters. The new Council will have overlapping majorities
held by Charlestown Democratic Town Committee-endorsed candidates and the
incumbent Charlestown Residents United (CRU) slate minus incumbent Craig Marr
(R/CRU) who lost his bid for reelection.
CCA candidate Sasha Pulchaski finished in sixth place losing
the final seat on the Council to incumbent Steve Stokes (R) who ran with the
endorsement of Charlestown Residents United (CRU). The election night results
favored Stokes by 34 votes but his lead shrank to 24 votes in the final count.
Puchalski is also asking for a recount.
The tri-town Chariho Unified Elementary School construction
bond issue is also being challenged, with Dianne Tefft (R) of Hopkinton asking for a
recount.
The final tally shows:
- · Charlestown
YES by 2,468 to NO 1,570;
- · Hopkinton
2,069 NO to 1,538 YES and
- · Richmond
1,899 NO to 1,682 YES.
The combined tally showed the Bond issue approval with 5,678
YES and 5,538 NO. The winning margin is 140 votes out of 11,256 ballots
counted. While both Hopkinton and Richmond voters rejected the bond issue, a
big 900 “yes” vote margin in Charlestown, site of the new school, delivered the
victory.
![]() |
| Tefft |
“I would like to make a motion in the language that all
three towns must share the expense of the one new school equally,” she said
as reported by
newly-elected Charlestown Town Council member Cynthia Drummond (D).
Charlestown Town Council President Deb Carney rebuttal to
Tefft was based on the Chariho Act that established the joint district that bases
funding from the towns based on their student enrollment percentages:
“Charlestown will vehemently oppose you trying to inflict one third of the cost on us…Right now, Charlestown pays more per student than Hopkinton, and we pay more per student than Richmond…Rest assured, we are not going to sit by and let you subject us to paying a third, when it’s not what the Chariho Act says.”



























