Trump and Bobby's continued war on vaccines
Jess Steier, DrPh
If you follow vaccine policy closely, you've probably learned to brace yourself on Friday afternoons. Just as the weekend rolls in, my team has a standing bet on the night's bombshell: guessing what gets pulled, which committee gets gutted, and which stack of evidence gets quietly waved away while the reporters log off. It started as a dark joke but stopped being funny a while ago.The pediatric childhood schedule fight has largely gone
quiet since March, when a court froze the administration's Advisory Committee
on Immunization Practices (ACIP) overhaul, even as the Friday personnel churn
rolled on. Now all the chips seem to be back on the table.
That habit of bracing—of trying to guess what’s coming
next—is one my father would have understood. He was a gambler who also taught
me chess, and two of his lessons have stuck with me. From the card table: Play
the player, not the cards. What someone is holding matters less than who they
are and what they want you to believe. From the chessboard: Think a few moves
ahead, because the move that decides a game is rarely the one that looks like
it’s doing something.
Lipstick on a weak argument
Both have been on my mind since the White House published an executive order on
Friday, May 29, titled “Realigning United States Core Childhood Vaccine
Recommendations with Best Practices from Peer, Developed Countries.”
“Executive order" has come to signal something swift
and unilateral, already in force before you can respond. This one plays on fear
without earning it. Read only the cards, and there's not much here. The order
tells the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and its ACIP to
review a federal “scientific assessment” (a December-ordered report comparing
the US childhood schedule with those of peer nations) and consider updates to
the childhood schedule.
On its own, the order does not change any recommendations,
not to mention there’s no functioning ACIP to act on it right now. It also
makes a point of stating that vaccines across all categories should remain
covered without cost-sharing by private insurance, Medicaid, the Children’s
Health Insurance Program (CHIP), and the Vaccines for Children Program. For
now, the schedule recommended by the CDC and American Academy of Pediatrics as
of 2025 remains in effect.















