CCA gives up on trying to regain control of the Town Council
Will Ruth Platner survive?
By Will Collette
For more than a decade, Charlestown politics has been dominated by the Charlestown Citizens Alliance (CCA) and those who oppose them, most recently Charlestown Residents United (CRU). Rituals like this year’s June 25 deadline for filing Declarations of Candidacy for election to municipal office became closely watched events.
For a decade, the CCA ruled Charlestown by creating
boogeymen to sow fear while turning Charlestown into a virtual gated
community for elderly rich people. That worked for a while until the CCA got
caught screwing up the town’s finances, a scandal highlighted by the “$3
million Oopsie.”
That cost the CCA control of the Charlestown Town Council in
2022 and their total ouster in 2024. In short order, the CRU
cleaned up the CCA’s money messes, according to the RI Auditor General.
In most recent election cycles, 10 people stepped up to
compete for the five Town Council seats. The CCA would field five and their
opposition would field five. This year, only eight people are running.
There are three declared Democrats: incumbent Council
President Deb Carney, retired journalist Cynthia Drummond and the close-second
finisher in last December’s Special Election Jill
Fonneman. Democrat/CRU incumbent Peter Slom is not running for re-election.
There are three declared Republican candidates: incumbents
Craig Marr and Steve Stokes as well as newcomer Matt Westover.
There are two “Unaffiliated” but CCA endorsed: Bonnita Van
Slyke and Sasha Puchalski.
Last year, the CCA made a minor comeback with CCA leader Ruth Platner getting her puppet Bonnita Van Slyke back onto the Council by a thin margin in a 3-way special election to fill the late Rippy Serra’s vacant seat.
But this year, the CCA has quietly surrendered by only
running Van Slyke as a bona fide CCA candidate. They have announced they are also endorsing “unaffiliated”
candidate Sasha Puchalski (daughter of the well-known Sandy Puchalski), though her
actual relationship to the CCA is unknown as this point.
They also endorsed two Council candidates who didn’t ask for
their endorsement. One is incumbent Steve
Stokes, a staunch CRU member running as a Republican. The other is Democrat
Cynthia Drummond who expressly told
South County Star editor Alex Nunes that the only endorsement she wanted
was that of the Charlestown Democratic Town Committee.
According
to Nunes, “Drummond said she will run as a Democrat endorsed by the
Charlestown Democratic Town Committee… She said she will not seek an
endorsement from either of the town’s rival political action committees,
Charlestown Citizens Alliance and Charlestown Residents United, although she
said both are supportive of her candidacy.”
So, the CCA election strategy is to endorse candidates
opposed to the CCA while running their old
warhorse Bonnita Van Slyke. The last time Bonnita Van Slyke ran for Council
in a General Election (2024), she ran dead last. Given her dubious record, it’s
unlikely she’ll do much better in November and will have to give up the seat she barely won
in the Special Election.
If the CCA is too feeble to run a full slate of its own
people, then stealing candidates from the opposition might be their way to
claim control.
I predict that after the votes are counted, the CCA will
issue a statement claiming “CCA-endorsed candidates win majorities on
Charlestown Town Council, Planning Commission and Chariho School Committee.”
CCA 2026 campaign cry: Save Ruthie!
It now looks like the CCA’s focus will be to preserve founding member and de facto leader Ruth Platner’s control of the Planning Commission.
Platner has used the Planning Commission to push her radical
agenda of blocking families with children by excluding affordable housing,
favoring rich beachfront property owners and acquiring land through shady
land deals. In recent elections, her vote tallies have denied her full
6-year terms, forcing her to run as an “alternate.”
Since she controls the CCA, she could then force the CCA
Planning Commission majority into naming her as Chair despite her vote tally.
But in the 2026 election, Platner could lose her CCA
majority on the Planning Commission. She herself is running for re-election as is
her sidekick Frances Topping plus two CCA acolytes Coleen Yaroshenko and Gordon
Willcox
Three non-CCA, CRU-leaning candidates are running against
them: Laura Rom, Katherine Gingras and Cheryl Lill.
Three current Planning Commission members whose terms expire
in 2028 and 2030 hold their seats. One is a Platner person (Sarah St. Laurent)
and two are not (Glenn Babcock and Patricia Stamp). CCA alternative member
Carol Ann Mossa is not seeking re-election and will leave the PC this year.
If Platner’s slate loses to the opposition, the new Planning
Commission majority may end Platner’s to Charlestown’s
Planning Commissar-For-Life position.
Indeed, there is a chance she could lose her seat. Including alternates, the Planning Commission has seven members. Three seats are held by incumbents. That leaves four seats up for grabs in November. There are seven people running, Ruth plus three CCA people and three anti-CCA people. Ruth has to finish in the top four of seven to hold onto her seat.
The last time there was a concerted effort to oust Platner, in 2018, she finished last in a field of four.
The CCA is also claiming by endorsement three candidates for
the Chariho School Committee: Holly Eaves, Linda Lyall and Craig Louzon. However,
all three are on the ballot as Democrats. The CCA’s primary voice on the School
Committee, Donna Chambers, died earlier this year.
Two guys are running for Town Moderator, an honorific post
whose only function is to chair the annual Charlestown budget meeting. CCA’s Dave
Wilkinson is running for re-election against Tony Jones who is running as a
Republican.
The next step is that these declared candidates will need to
gather 50 signatures of registered Charlestown voters to get their names on the
ballot.
I’m not running
I repeat: I am not running against our terrific incumbent state Rep. Tina Spears in the September 9 Democratic Primary despite being listed as a candidate on the Secretary of State's website.
It’s a paperwork glitch – my fault. When I filed my declaration to remain a member of the Democratic House District 36 Committee,
I checked the wrong box. I’ve already notified the Charlestown Board of
Canvassers and will do whatever I need to do to withdraw. And since I’m not
going to collect any signatures, I will not be on the ballot.
As Civil War hero Gen. William Tecumseh Sherman said in 1884, "If nominated, I will not run. If elected, I will not serve."














