Not with a bang but a whimper.
By Thom Hartmann for the Independent Media Institute
 |
| By Matt Davies |
Longtime readers of my
work and listeners to my program know that the Supreme Court has seized for
itself extraordinary powers that the Framers of the Constitution never intended
for it to have. There are summaries here and here, for example.
This is not an opinion
unique to me or my book The Hidden
History of the Supreme Court and the Betrayal of America: two Harvard Law professors just this week wrote an article for
The Atlantic that lays out pretty much the same arguments.
And now Republicans on
the Court have used that ill-gotten power — on behalf of the fossil fuel
industry — to cripple America’s ability to meet the challenge of climate
change.
It’s a bizarre concept
and just a fig-leaf to hide the fossil fuel industry’s desire to end government
regulation and kill subsidies of green energy. To get there, they’ve turned
regulatory agency rule-making upside-down.
Here’s how
environmental law is supposed to work (in super-simplified form):
1.
Congress passes a law
that says, for example, that the Environmental Protection Agency should limit
the damage that carbon dioxide in the environment causes to the planet.
Congress (the Constitution’s Article I branch of government) defines the broad
goal of the legislation, but the Executive Branch (Article II) has the
responsibility to carry it out.
2.
The EPA, part of that
Executive Branch and answering both to the law and the President, then convenes
panels of experts. They spend a year or more doing an exhaustive, deep dive
into the science, coming up with dozens or even hundreds of suggestions to
limit atmospheric CO2, ranging from rules on how much emission cars can expel
to drilling and refining processes that may leak CO2 or methane (which degrades
into CO2), etc.
3.
The experts’
suggestions are then run past a panel of rule-making bureaucrats and hired-gun
rule-making experts for the EPA to decide what the standards should be. They
take into consideration the current abilities of industry and the costs versus
the benefits of various rules, among other things.
4.
After they’ve come up
with those tentative regulations, they submit them for public review and
hearings. When that process is done and the rules are approved, they make them
into official EPA rules, publish them, enforce them, and the CO2 emissions
begin to drop.
This is how it works,
a process that simply comports with common sense, as the Supreme Court ruled in 1984. It’s
been this way for a century or more.