Trump to students: don't go to college
Education Secretary Betsy DeVos is
back in the news on a topic close to my heart: student loans.
It’s close to my heart because I’m
six years into a PhD program and six figures in debt right now.
While my life
has been immeasurably enriched by my education, I’m not taking on this amount
of debt simply because I love learning.
Like anyone, I’m doing it because I
need a job.
My student loans were a calculation
of risk vs. reward: I took on this debt because I believed doing so would
result in eventually finding a secure, well-paying job that would allow me to
pay it back and then some.
Just the learning, or even the degree alone, will
not be worth it unless my degree leads me to a job.
That’s the calculation students make
when they take out student loans.
Education is a ticket to many salaried,
middle class jobs, yet higher education is financially out of reach for many
without loans.
Sociologist Sara Goldrick-Rab has
documented many ways in which our existing financial aid system does not
adequately serve the needs of low-income students — because it was created
based on assumptions true of wealthier students only.
For example, typical aid
calculations assume that parents will contribute to their children’s education,
and children won’t be working to contribute to their parents’ household income.
Some students take out loans but
don’t finish their degree — and they are left in debt with nothing to show for
it. These are not lazy students. They are often working one or more jobs,
sometimes raising children, and trying to go to college while living in
poverty. Attempting to attend college leaves them worse off than if they had
not tried at all.